List of historical unrecognized states

These lists of historic unrecognized or partially recognized states or governments give an overview of extinct geopolitical entities, that wished to be recognized as sovereign states, but did not enjoy worldwide diplomatic recognition. The entries listed here had de facto control over their claimed territory and were self-governing with a desire for full independence, or if they lacked such control over their territory, were recognized by at least one other recognized nation.

Contents

Criteria for inclusion

The criteria for inclusion in this list is similar to that of the List of states with limited recognition. To be included here, a polity must have claimed statehood, lacked recognition from at least one state, and either:

Historic unrecognized or partially recognized states with de facto control over their territory

Note: The tables can be sorted alphabetically or chronologically using the icon.

Europe

Name Period Today Notes
Alsace Alsace-Lorraine 1918 Part of France Short-lived Independent Republic of Alsace-Lorraine.
Asturias and León Sovereign Council of Asturias and León 1937 Part of Spain Its independence was declared from the Second Spanish Republic (24 August) and it was occupied by the Francoist Forces during the Spanish Civil War (21 October). Its government (called traditionally "El Gobiernín") asked the League of Nations for international recognition but it was occupied before receiving an answer.
Asturias Workers and Peasants' Republic of Asturias 1934 Part of Spain The Revolutionary Forces during the October Revolution (1934) rejecting the Conservative Government of the Second Spanish Republic asked the republican government for independence. It was not recognized. The Spanish Army, led by Francisco Franco occupied the region.
Banat Banat Republic 1918 Part of Romania, Serbia, and Hungary
Baranya-Baja Serbian-Hungarian Baranya-Baja Republic 1921 Part of Hungary and Croatia
Bavaria Bavarian Soviet Republic 1919 Part of Germany
Belarus Belarusian People's Republic 1918 Independent Belarus
Carpatho-Ukraine Carpatho-Ukraine 1939 Part of Ukraine
Italian Regency of Carnaro Italian Regency of Carnaro 1919–1920 Part of Croatia Proclaimed by Gabriele D'Annunzio.
Catalan Republic Catalan Republic 1931, 1934 Part of Spain The independent Catalan Republic was proclaimed twice. First, in April 1931 by Francesc Macià, following which it submitted to the soveregnity of the Second Spanish Republic. The second time it was proclaimed by Macià's successor as the President of the Generalitat, Lluís Companys, on October 6, 1934. His rebellion was quickly crushed by the Spanish central government.
Chechnya  Chechen Republic of Ichkeria 1991–2000 Part of Russia Reintegrated into the Russian Federation as the Chechen Republic
Connaught  Republic of Connaught 1798 Part of the Republic of Ireland French client republic
Corsica Kingdom of Corsica 1736 Part of France Seceded from Republic of Genoa
Corsican Republic 1755–1769 Part of France Seceded from Republic of Genoa; annexed by France. Recognized only by Bey of Tunis[1]
Corsica Anglo-Corsican Kingdom 1794–1796 Part of France Independent kingdom under British King George III, formed on the Irish model[2][3]
Crimea Republic of Crimea 1992, 1994–1995 Part of Ukraine Declared in 1992 and again in 1994, spanning the Crimean peninsula. Was ended through negotiations with Ukraine[4][5].
Croatia  Independent State of Croatia 1941–1945 Now two independent states, Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina Puppet state of Nazi Germany.
Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia  Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia 1992–1994 Part of Bosnia and Herzegovina
Gagauzia Gagauzia 1990–1994 Part of Moldova
East Germany  German Democratic Republic 1949–1990 Part of Federal Republic of Germany Was not recognized for a time by West Germany and several other countries.
Finnish Socialist Workers' Republic  Finnish Socialist Workers' Republic 1918 Part of Finland Lasted only three months during Finnish Civil War, but was recognized by Soviet Russia.
Goust  Republic of Goust Part of France[6]
Idel-Ural Idel-Ural State 1917–1918 Part of Tatarstan and Bashkortostan (Russia) Suppressed by Red Army.
Ireland Irish Republic 1919–1922 Divided into Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland
Kuban Kuban People's Republic 1918–1920 Part of Russia
Latjtabansag Lajtabánság 1921 Part of Austria and Hungary
Mirdita Republic of Mirdita 1921 Part of Albania
Munster Munster Republic 1922 Part of Republic of Ireland
Pindus-Macedonia Principality of Pindus and Voivodship of Macedonia 1941–1944 Part of Greece and Macedonia
Prekmurje Republic of Prekmurje 1919 Part of Slovenia[7] Existed for 6 days.
Republika Srpska  Republika Srpska 1992–1995 One of the two entities of Bosnia and Herzegovina Transformed into an entity of Bosnia and Herzegovina, covering 50% of the land with 90%+ ethnic Serbs.
Serbian Krajina Republic of Serbian Krajina 1991–1995 Part of Croatia Suppressed by Croatia. After the Operation Storm of the Croatian army almost all ethnic Serbs fled Croatia.[8] A number of Croatian army officers were indicted by the ICTY for the atrocities committed against the civilian Serb population.[9]
Slovakia 1 Slovak Soviet Republic 1919 Part of Slovakia
Slovakia 2 First Slovak Republic 1939–1945 Part of Slovakia Between 1939-1945, First Slovak Republic was a puppet state of Nazi Germany.
State of Slovenes, Croats and Serbs State of Slovenes, Croats and Serbs 1918 Part of Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia-Hercegovina, Serbia (Vojvodina) and Montenegro (Boka Kotorska) Temporary state of the Austro-Hungarian South Slavs, declared on October 29, 1918 and merged with the Kingdom of Serbia on December 1, 1918 into the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes (Yugoslavia)
Tavolara Kingdom of Tavolara 1836–1962? Part of Italy[10] Recognized by the Kingdom of Sardinia and the Kingdom of Italy; acknowledged by Queen Victoria.
Ukraine 1 Ukrainian People's Republic 1917–1920 Part of Ukraine
Ukraine 2 Ukrainian State 1919 Part of Ukraine
Ukraine, West West Ukrainian People's Republic 1918–1919 Part of Ukraine
Ukraine, Free Territory  Free Territory 1918–1921 Part of Ukraine
Uzice  Republic of Užice 1941 Part of Serbia
Western Bosnia Republic of West Bosnia 1993–1995 Part of Bosnia and Herzegovina

Asia

Name Period Today Notes
Aceh Sultanate of Aceh 1874–1904 Now part of Indonesia
Alash Alash Autonomy 1917–1920 Now part of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan De facto self-governing
Ararat Republic of Ararat 1927–1930 Now part of Turkey
Azad Hind Arzi Hukumat-e-Azad Hind 1943–1945 Part of India The Provisional Government of Free India was recognized by 9 nations. Its sovereignty was limited to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and parts of northeast India.
Azerbaijan People's Government Azerbaijan People's Government 1945–1946 Now part of Iran
Republic of Biak-na-Bato Republic of Biak-na-Bato 1897 Now part of the Philippines
East Timor Democratic Republic of East Timor 1975 Recognized as independent in 2002 Declaration of independence in 1975 recognized by six states (Albania, Cape Verde, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Mozambique, São Tomé and Príncipe)
East Turkestan 1 First East Turkestan Republic 1933–1934 Now part of China
East Turkestan 2 Second East Turkestan Republic 1944–1949 Now part of China
Formosa Republic of Formosa 1895 Now base of the Republic of China (Taiwan) Declared independence upon cession of Taiwan to Japan following First Sino-Japanese War
Kurdistan Kingdom of Kurdistan 1921–1924 Now part of Iraq
Mahabad Republic of Mahabad 1946–1947 Now part of Iran
Manchukuo  Manchukuo 1932–1945 Part of China Puppet government dissolved at the end of World War II
Mongolian People's Republic  Mongolia 1932–1945 Now independent Was not recognized by several countries from 1940-1960 due to being claimed as integral part of the Republic of China.[11]
Negros Cantonal Republic of Negros 1898–1901 Now part of the Philippines. Declared independence and aligned itself with the First Philippine Republic. Later, it was recognized by the United States, however the government was dissolved by the Americans in 1901.
Persian SSR Persian Socialist Soviet Republic 1920–1921 Now Gilan province in Iran Created by local guerilleros (Jangali) when Red Army troops entered Iran, but failed to spread the revolutionary movement over the whole Iran
Philippines Philippine Republic 1899–1901 Now part of the Philippines Existed as an unrecognized independent state from its declaration on June 12, 1898 up to the Treaty of Paris on December 10, by which Spain ceded the Philippines to the United States. It was formally established with the proclamation of the Malolos Constitution on January 23, 1899 in Malolos, Bulacan, and pursued an unsuccessful war of independence against the United States in the Philippine-American War
South Moluccas

Republic of South Moluccas

1950 Now part of Indonesia
Suvadive Islands Suvadive Islands 1959–1963 Now part of the Maldives
Tagalog Repbulic (Bonifacio) Sovereign Tagalog Nation 1896–1897 Now part of the Philippines. Succeeded by First Philippine Republic.
Tagalog Republic (Sacay) Tagalog Republic 1902–1906 Now part of the Philippines.
Tamil Eelam Tamil Eelam 1983–2009 Now part of Sri Lanka and India See Sri Lankan Civil War
Tannu Tuva  Tannu Tuva 1921–1944 Now part of Russia
Tibet Tibet 1913–1951 Now part of China,Nepal, and India In 1913, Thubten Gyatso, 13th Dalai Lama of Tibet declared independence from China,[12] which was only recognized by Mongolia[13][14] (however, there have been doubts over the authority of the Tibetan representative to sign the treaty, and thus its validity).[15] One year later the Dalai Lama signed a UK-drafted treaty accepting Chinese suzerainty and adjusting the border in favor of British India.[16] The 14th Dalai Lama acknowledged Chinese sovereignty in the Seventeen Point Agreement of 1951,[17] but China continues to reject the 1914 UK-drafted treaty and claims South Tibet (now part of India's Arunachal Pradesh).
Wang Jingwei Wang Jingwei Government 1940–1945 Part of China Puppet government dissolved at the end of World War II. Recognized by Imperial Japan and its allies.
Zamboanga Republic of Zamboanga 1899–1903 Now part of the Philippines. República de Zamboanga was short-lived revolutionary republic, founded after the collapse of Spanish colonial rule in the Philippines, In the year 1899.

Africa

Name Period Today Notes
Biafra  Biafra 1967–1970 Part of Nigeria Controlled territory in eastern Nigeria, recognized by five states (Gabon, Haiti, Ivory Coast, Tanzania, Zambia)
Anjouan  Anjouan 1997–2002,
2008
Now part of Comoros
Bophuthatswana  Bophuthatswana,
 Ciskei,
 Transkei,
 Venda
1977–1994,
1981–1994,
1976–1994,
1979–1994
Now all part of South Africa Former apartheid Bantustan homelands, formed and recognized only by each other and South Africa. Israel extended marginal recognition to Bophuthatswana and Ciskei by allowing both polities to build trade missions in Tel Aviv
Guinea-Bissau Guinea-Bissau 1972–1973 Independent state Declared its independence in 1972 and received recognition from 65 states. Accepted into the UN after substantial opposition from several states. Portugal renounced its sovereignty over the territory in 1973. [18]
Jubaland Jubaland 1998–2001 Now part of Southwestern Somalia
Katanga Katanga 1960–1964 Part of the Democratic Republic of the Congo Controlled the state of the same name within the former Belgian Congo after decolonisation
Moheli Mohéli 1997–1998 Now part of Comoros
Rhodesia  Rhodesia 1965–1979 Now Zimbabwe British Colony that unilaterally declared independence
Rif  Republic of the Rif 1921–1926 Part of Morocco Founded in September 1921, when the people of the Rif (the Riffians) revolted and declared their independence from Spanish Morocco. It was dissolved by Spanish and French forces on 27 May 1926.
Rwenzururu Kingdom of Rwenzururu 1963–1982 Now part of Uganda Was based in the Rwenzori Mountains between Uganda and Congo
Zimbabwe Rhodesia  Zimbabwe Rhodesia 1979–1980 Now Zimbabwe Short-lived state that ended white minority government and introduced biracial government

Americas

Name Period Today Notes
Acre Republic of Acre 1899–1903 Now part of Brazil
Anguilla Republic of Anguilla 1967-1969 Now a British overseas territory
Anguilla Kingdom of Araucanía and Patagonia 1860-1862 Now part of Argentina and Chile
California California Republic 1846 Now part of the United States Was also known as Bear Flag Republic
Confederate States of America  Confederate States of America 1861–1865 Now part of the United States Originally formed by seven states (South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Texas, and Louisiana). After the American Civil War began, the states of Virginia, Tennessee, Arkansas, and North Carolina joined. Recognized by some nations as a "belligerent power". Reintegrated into the United States.
Indian Stream  Republic of Independent Guyana 1886–1891 Part of Amapa, Brazil Established by French settlers in defiance of both France and Brazil
Indian Stream  Republic of Indian Stream 1832–1835 Now part of the United States Annexed by the United States. Within the state of New Hampshire
Juliana Juliana Republic 1839 Part of Brazil Today's Santa Catarina
Madawaska Republic of Madawaska 1827–1842 Now divided between Canada and the United States Within the provinces of New Brunswick and Quebec and the state of Maine
Muskogee State of Muskogee 1799–1832 Part of the United States A short-lived Native American state in Florida; consisted of several tribes of Creeks and Seminoles. Annexed by US.
Piratini Piratini Republic 1836–1845 Part of Brazil Today's Rio Grande do Sul
Rio Grande Republic of the Río Grande 1840 Now part of the United States and Mexico
Vermont Vermont Republic 1777–1791 Now part of the United States Became the State of Vermont
Watauga  Watauga Association 1772–1778 Now part of the United States Annexed into the State of North Carolina
West Florida Free and Independent Republic of West Florida 1810 Now part of the United States Short-lived republic consisting of parts of Louisiana, Mississippi, Florida and Alabama. Annexed during James Madison presidency.
Yucatán  Republic of Yucatán 1841–1843 & 1846–1848 Part of Mexico
 Republic of Texas 1836-1845 Now part of the United States

Oceania

Name Period Today Notes
Bougainville Bougainville Interim Government 1990-1998 Part of Papua New Guinea Signed a peace deal with Papua New Guinea giving the island autonomy pending an independence referendum within a decade
Franceville Independent Commune of Franceville 1889 Part of Vanuatu Its independence guaranteed by France, this community of Melanesian natives and European settlers experimented with universal suffrage until France and Britain intervened in the New Hebrides[19]
New Zealand United Tribes of New Zealand 1835–1840 Now New Zealand Independence declared in 1835 and was recognised by the United Kingdom. Became a British colony in 1840
North Solomons Republic of North Solomons 1975–1976 Part of Papua New Guinea
Tafea Tafea Nation 1980 Part of Vanuatu
Tanna Tanna Nation 1974 Part of Vanuatu
Vemerana Republic of Vemerana 1980 Part of Vanuatu Central power of Vanuatu restored with assistance of army from Papua New Guinea

Historic unrecognized or partially recognized governments with de facto control over their territory

These regimes had control over the territory of a country for which most other states recognized a different government as being the legitimate government:

Name Period Today Notes
People's Republic of Kampuchea 1979–1989 Now Cambodia Pro-Vietnamese government led by Heng Samrin after the fall of the Khmer Rouge-ruled Democratic Kampuchea. Democratic Kampuchea continued to be recognized by more states than the PRK and continued to control Cambodia's seat at the United Nations.
Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan 1996–2001 Now Afghanistan Taliban government of Afghanistan. Only recognized by three states (Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates) during its existence. See: History of Afghanistan and Islamic State of Afghanistan.

See also

References

  1. ^ Thrasher, Peter Adam (1970). Pasquale Paoli: An Enlightened Hero 1725-1807. Hamden, CT: Archon Books. p. 117. ISBN 0208010319. 
  2. ^ Thrasher, Peter Adam (1970). Pasquale Paoli: An Enlightened Hero 1725-1807. Hamden, Connecticut: Archon Books. pp. 282. ISBN 0208010319. 
  3. ^ Gregory, Desmond (1985). The ungovernable rock: a history of the Anglo-Corsican Kingdom and its role in Britain's Mediterranean strategy during the Revolutionary War, 1793-1797. London: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press. pp. 81–82. ISBN 0838632254. 
  4. ^ Autonomous Republic of Crimea
  5. ^ Encyclopedia of the United Nations ... - Google Books
  6. ^ Goust photo - jmollivier photos at pbase.com
  7. ^ Mocsy
  8. ^ Marcus Tanner (1997). Croatia: a nation forged in war. Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300069334. http://books.google.com/books?id=gfSyQgAACAAJ. 
  9. ^ [1]
  10. ^ Geremia, Ernesto Carlo, and Gino Ragnetti (2005), Tavolara - l'Isola dei Re, ISBN 8-84253-441-2
  11. ^ http://books.google.com.mx/books?id=tPMUm0idWw8C&printsec=frontcover&hl=es#v=onepage&q&f=false
  12. ^ Proclamation Issued by His Holiness the Dalai Lama XIII (1913)
  13. ^ Udo B. Barkmann, Geschichte der Mongolei, Bonn 1999, p380ff
  14. ^ Phurbu Thinley (2008-11-12). "Tibet - Mongolia Treaty of 1913, a proof of Tibet’s independence: Interview with Prof. Elliot Sperling". Phayul.com. http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?article=Tibeto-Mongol+Treaty+of+1913%2C+a+proof+of+Tibet%E2%80%99s+independence%3A+Interview&id=23205. Retrieved 2008-11-13. 
  15. ^ Smith, Warren, "Tibetan Nation", p. 186: "The validity is often questioned, mainly on grounds of the authority of Dorjiev to negotiate on behalf of Tibet...the fact that Dorjiev was a Russian citizen while ethnically Tibetan somewhat compromises his role; the treaty had some advantages to Russia in that it could be interpreted as extending Russia's protectorate over Mongolia to encompass Tibet.
  16. ^ Convention Between Great Britain, China, and Tibet, Simla (1914)
  17. ^ Goldstein, Melvyn C., A History of Modern Tibet, 1913-1951, University of California Press, 1989, pp812-813, saying: "After a lengthy discussion...the assembly recommended to the Dalai Lama that the agreement be approved. On 24 October, the Dalai Lama sent an official confirmation to Mao Tse-tung."
  18. ^ Unlawful territorial situations in ... - Google Books
  19. ^ "Wee, Small Republics: A Few Examples of Popular Government", Hawaiian Gazette, Nov 1, 1895, p 1